The Putnam Examiner

Odell Opposes Changes to STAR that Could Punish Homeowners

We are part of The Trust Project

Putnam County Executive MaryEllen Odell voiced her opposition this week to a state budget change that punishes homeowners who have fallen behind on their property taxes by taking away their Basic STAR tax exemption.

The Basic STAR program, which started in the 1990s, is an upfront exemption on school taxes that saves the average principal homeowner in New York State about $800 year. As of this year, however, those who are more than a year late on their property taxes will no longer qualify for the exemption. The Enhanced STAR program, which gives senior citizens a larger property tax break, is not affected by the change.

“This is not a time to penalize homeowners who have fallen behind in their property tax payments,” Odell said. “Those who can’t pay their taxes are being kicked out of STAR — the very program that is designed to ease the property tax burden. These kind of budget shenanigans may make state finances look better, but they amount to nothing more than hitting people when they are down.”

Governor Andrew Cuomo has advocated to eliminate the upfront reduction in the school tax bill that STAR offers and replace it with a STAR credit check that is sent to homeowners in the fall. When the state pays STAR by a rebate check, it is considered a revenue reduction rather than state spending, thus allowing the state to keep spending under the 2 % cap.

The NYS Department of Taxation and Finance announced that it plans to send letters on May 22 to those who will be kicked out of the Basic STAR program.

When homeowners lose their STAR exemption, it ultimately hurts the county, said William Carlin Jr., the Putnam County Commissioner of Finance.

“Without the STAR exemption, we expect there will be an increase in the number of homeowners who can’t pay their taxes,” Carlin said. “A lost STAR exemption ultimately hurts the county. The county is responsible for guaranteeing taxes to the school districts. If delinquent property taxpayers aren’t allowed the STAR exemption, it means the county will have to pay the school districts that much more.”

In addition to the school taxes, the county also guarantees town and village taxes each year at a current amount of approximately $25 million. Once property owners have been kicked out of the Basic Star Exemption program, they are removed forever. When they pay their taxes, they may qualify for the STAR rebate check.

Since 1995, Putnam County has offered a two-year payment plan for those who are unable to pay their entire property tax bill on time.

State Assemblyman Kevin Byrne (R), who represents Putnam County, could not be reached for comment.


We'd love for you to support our work by joining as a free, partial access subscriber, or by registering as a full access member. Members get full access to all of our content, and receive a variety of bonus perks like free show tickets. Learn more here.